Garlick Not Pizza Reviews

I ordered from garlicknotpizza.com the crust ruined it for me. It was tough and weirdly chewy, like it had been sitting around for way too long. I felt like I was wasting energy just trying to bite through the edges. Definitely not ordering from there again.

The pizza was good overall, and the cheese actually tasted really nice. I just wish they’d put a little more on there, because pizza is basically all about the cheese for everyone

I ordered from garlicknotpizza.com and the site gave me a bit of a headache. It was loading super slow, and for some reason I had to type in my address twice, which was annoying.

The checkout part wasn’t great either. The total changed right at the end and I couldn’t really tell why, so I just sat there wondering if I missed something. I did get the confirmation email, but it took longer then I expected.

The food did arrive, so it wasn’t a total disaster or anything. But the online ordering definetly needs some work. Not the worst experience ever, just more frustrating than it needed to be.

I’ve ordered from here twice now, and both times the pizza showed up hot and actually tasted good. I don’t have the patience for overpriced food or tiny portions, so I was happy the prices were fair and the servings were decent. Definitely add the garlic knots, they’re worth it. No real complaints from me.

I ordered the garlic knots because they sounded like they’d be loaded with flavor, but they were disappointing. They mostly just tasted like plain bread with maybe the faintest hint of garlic, and they were kind of dry too. I hate when places make something sound like it’s going to be really flavorful and then it’s just... not. Definitely wouldn’t order them again.

I tried placing an order, my card got charged, and then the order still showed as failed. that feels unfair—if a payment doesn’t go through properly, the customer shouldn’t be the one left stressing about where their money went.

I was already in a hungry and impatient mood, so I got excited when I saw a couple of deals on the site. But when I tried to use them, they were either gone or wouldn’t apply at checkout. That was the main reason I chose them over another pizza place, so it was frustrating. The site made it seem like there was a special available, but then nothing actually worked. Felt like a waste of time

The pizza was alright, maybe even good if you’re just looking for something quick. But the staff didn’t really come across as friendly when I ordered, and I felt like I was kind of annoying them just by being there. It’s not a terrible spot or anything, I just didn’t love the vibe

The pizza finally showed up, but it was barely warm, kind of a heartbreaking moment when I opened the box expecting cheesy glory and got lukewarm disappointment instead.

Umm, everything came right this time, so that was nice. They just forgot one extra sauce, but otherwise the order was good.

Just a quick warning for anyone ordering — my pizza showed up way faster than I expected. Not complaining at all, it was a nice surprise, but be ready because they don’t mess around with delivery time.

I ordered from garlicknotpizza.com thinking it would be one of those easy, cozy dinners where nobody has to cook and we just eat while watching something. Instead, I mostly remember sitting there checking the tracking over and over, watching it barely move, and getting more frustrated as the evening dragged on. It took almost 2 hours to arrive.

By the time the food finally showed up, the whole mood was gone. We weren’t even that hungry anymore, just tired and annoyed. I understand delays can happen, but not getting any real update or even a quick apology made it feel like nobody cared.

Ordered from garlicknotpizza.com last Friday, and my snap judgment? Solid. The garlic knots were definitely the best part, and the pizza showed up warm enough to enjoy. Delivery ran a little later than they estimated, which was annoying, but not a dealbreaker. Overall, I was happy with it and I’d order again.

I ordered for pickup thinking it would be quick and easy, but it felt like more effort than just shopping in person. I ended up waiting longer than I expected, and the pickup area was confusing to figure out. On top of that, nobody really seemed to know where my order was, so I had to keep asking around. It was just a hassle from start to finish. Next time I’ll probably go somewhere that makes pickup less of a chore.

I ordered from garlicknotpizza.com what a joke. The sauce tasted really off, way too sweet, kind of watery, and it had this weird aftertaste I couldn’t get past. It pretty much ruined the whole pizza for me. Definitely not ordering from there again

I ordered the pizza expecting a decent meal for the price, but it was tiny. It was barely enough for one hungry person, and when I mentioned it, it kind of felt like my concern was brushed off. Disappointing.

I went in thinking it’d be a normal pizza place, but the vibe was not great, haha. It was really loud, the tables felt way too close together, and the place looked a little messy, so it wasn’t super relaxing to sit there.
The staff seemed like they were rushing around and stressed out, which kind of made the whole thing feel more uncomfortable. Maybe it’s better if you just grab takeout, but for dining in, it really wasn’t worth it for me.

I was happy to see they had some vegan options, which was a nice surprise. But when I asked about the ingredients, the staff seemed a little unsure, and that made me nervous. I’d definitely recommend checking carefully before ordering if you have dietary restrictions.

They did end up fixing the issue, but it took way longer than I expected (which was frustrating). It wasn’t a terrible experience, just not exactly great either

I had a small special request and they handled it without any fuss. I also got the receipt by email right away, which was helpful. Overall, really easy experience.